logo

Stew Lilker’s

Columbia County Observer

Real news from Florida for working families since 2007

County News: Fort White

Fort White ‘Emergency’ Shredder Meeting Collapses Amid Sunshine Law Warnings – The After-Meeting Was Worse


FORT WHITE, FL — Last night, Nov. 18, an emergency meeting of the Fort White Town Council imploded in less than 12 minutes after Town Attorney Leonard Ireland warned council members over a static-filled phone line that investigating bags of shredded paper did not constitute a legal emergency.

The “emergency” meeting, called by Mayor George Jacob Thomas for 5:30 p.m., gave the public approximately 3 hours’ notice, while the media received zero.

The meeting ended without any formal votes, and the board allowed no public comments, even though the newly elected claimed it was entering a new era of transparency.

The aborted meeting showed a town council oblivious to Florida’s open government mandates and abandoning its parliamentary rules to keep public business orderly and transparent.

The after-meeting was worse.

Trash Bags Wound Up the Mayor. The Result — a Town “Emergency” because he was “concerned”

The full council attended the Mayor-declared emergency. The Town’s recently elected District 1 representative, Dennis Rivera, also happens to be the County’s PIO, who is supposed to be an expert in public notice and information. If the short notice caught his attention, he wasn’t talking. Two of the Town’s attorneys were on the phone, Leonard Ireland and Katie Holloway.

The only other issue brought up by the Council as the meeting got underway was raised by newly elected Councilman Alex Veiga, who pointed out that his name was misspelled on the notice.

Nobody caught the defective notice’s fine print, which contained a notice for disabled residents seeking accommodations for “City Commission meetings” to contact the “City Clerk” in “High Springs, Florida.”

Under Florida law and Attorney General Opinions, a local charter cannot dilute Sunshine Law protections: reasonable notice is owed to the public, not merely to elected officials, who were clueless about the actual purpose of the meeting.

Short Notice: only four relevant words


The Town Attorney appeared by phone. The Town's IT director was not notified of the meeting and didn't prepare a more viable setup.

Mayor Thomas then revealed why he called the meeting on such short notice. "Speaking to a town employee, I received a report that there are shredded documents likely coming from Town Hall being put into the trash cans.” He added, "I'm not necessarily claiming that there's a destruction of records. I am claiming that I am very concerned, and I do believe that this council needs to take action."

The Mayor did not explain where one would put the garbage instead.

Attorney Ireland (of counsel at FoldsWalker – second from right) urged immediate adjournment, asking if the Mayor received his memorandum “a couple of hours ago.”

Mayor Thomas said he was told about it.

Fort White’s agenda description listed only four cryptic words — "Town staff emergency action" — not giving citizens or council members any clue that records or personnel were an issue.

Mr. Ireland said his opinion was based on legal research:

This is not enough notice for any emergencies or something where the fire got burned down, something of that nature. The second thing is that the notice that I saw doesn't give anybody notice of what the meeting is about… So, my advice, you can do whatever you want to do as you will, is that the next thing you do is adjourn and give proper notice. Some documents being shredded or something of that nature, which I just heard –- I suggest strongly is not an emergency.

Mayor Thomas: not on board

The Mayor was not buying into it. “Okay. Thank you, Mr. Ireland. Okay, so the Town Attorney's opinion is if there's Town documents being shredded, that's not an emergency. That's his legal opinion. Thank you, Mr. Ireland. I'm surprised to hear that.”


Earl Jenkins explains the trash in the garbage can.

Mayor Thomas invited Fort White maintenance worker Earl Jenkins to speak. Mr. Jenkins told the Council that after Town Hall employees repeatedly left garbage cans out past Monday pickups, while claiming they had not taken trash out, he checked inside and photographed shredded paper. On Monday morning, he found another bag [of garbage] hidden beneath other garbage. "At the bottom, there was a bunch of shredded bags of, uh, shredded paper," Mr. Jenkins said, describing tense office dynamics "between the two parties" in which staffers blamed "Kelly" and warned him "not to speak to y'all. I wasn't supposed to speak to anybody." (It was not clear exactly what Mr. Jenkins was talking about)

Get the Garbage – the Council Unravels


The evidence brought back to the Council Chambers by Mr. Jenkins.

Councilman Veiga asked Mr. Jenkins to fetch the bag of shredded paper. He walked outside to fetch it.

Parliamentary order unraveled. Although the council is supposed to follow Robert’s Rules of Order, requiring speakers to be recognized by the chair, prohibiting debate without a pending motion, and barring the chair from making motions from the dais, Mayor Thomas made both the opening motion to approve the agenda and the closing motion to adjourn while Vice Mayor Merricks called for the votes. As Mr. Jenkins stepped out, Councilman Koon initiated an unguided council brainstorm, asking if they could act "for tomorrow that would keep anything else from happening" or have someone told, "not to show up tomorrow."


Alex Veiga photo from his social media of November 13, after the election. Obviously, he still hasn't read it.

Council members repeatedly spoke without recognition, talking directly over Town Attorney Ireland, even as he warned, "Number two, you could be subject to criminal sanctions. So, it's not a thing to play around with."

An Abrupt Adjournment: “We’re not even having a meeting.”

After the undirected Council conversation, Councilman Veiga said, “What he’s (Ireland) saying is we’re not even having a meeting.” Vice Mayor Merricks agreed. “Right.”

Earlier, Councilman Koon asked if Clerk MacPherson “could ask her (Christy Thompson – the temporary asstant clerk) not to show up tomorrow?”

Mayor Thomas answered, “Yeah. The clerk could do that.”

Vice Mayor Merricks said, “Whatever Kelly does after this, that's on Kelly, but I think we make the motion to adjourn and then Kelly does whatever she needs to do to protect the office.”

Again, with needless handing over of the gavel, Fort White’s Town Council adjourned the meeting.

That Wasn’t the End of It: The Post-Meeting – Meeting

Did Curiosity Kill the Cat?

Councilman and PIO Dennis Rivera and Councilman Bill Koon hightailed out of the meeting. Mayor Thomas, Vice Mayor Merricks, and Councilman Veiga lingered, along with Ms. Merrick’s sister, Earl Jenkins, and Three Rivers resident and Councilman Veiga's neighbor in Three Rivers, Enrique Simon-Felipe.

The unopened bag of garbage Earl Jenkins left was resting against the wall. It was too much for the two Councilmembers and Mayor to resist.

Ms. Merricks took a moment, looked at the bag, and, like an early-discovered Christmas present, couldn’t resist. She bent over, untied the knot, and began taking out shredded paper and “this looks like somebody’s lunch,” she said. Then she told your reporter not to take photos.


From left to right: Mayor Thomas, Vice Mayor Merricks (head in garbage), Earl Jenkins, Enrique Feliipe, Mr. Adventure Awaits, Councilman Alex Veiga. Mr. Veiga is trying to assemble the strips of paper.

Sporting a T-shirt with an “Adventure Awaits” logo, Councilman Veiga also dove into the bag, coming out with a handful of shredded paper. Mayor Thomas, like the driver of a getaway car, looked on without putting on the brakes. It wasn’t a pretty sight.

By 7 pm, everyone had filed out of Town Hall, except Clerk MacPherson, who left sometime after 7 pm.


After trying to let herself in and discovering the locks on Town Hall were changed, Ms. MacPherson opened her car door and told Ms. Thompson she was terminated the day before.

Today, November 19, at 9 am, Christy Thompson showed up for work. Clerk MacPherson, still in her car, told her that her services weren’t needed anymore, and the temp agency was notified “yesterday.”

If the temp agency was notified on Monday, nobody mentioned it during the meeting, when Vice Mayor Merricks remarked, “Whatever Kelly does after this, that’s on Kelly.”

At 3:45 pm today, Ms. Thompson told your reporter, “Nobody has contacted me from the temp agency.”

With Fort White careening out of control, it is reported that the Fort White saga is to continue on Monday evening, the twenty-third, with another special meeting. As of publication, the notice has not been published on the Town website.

Update November 20, 6:35 am: added date in first line

Comments  (to add a comment go here)